Julie has just retired. Her company’s retirement program has two options as to how retirement benefits can be received. Under the first option, Julie would receive a lump sum of $140,000 immediately as her full retirement benefit. Under the second option, she would receive $27,000 each year for 5 years plus a lump-sum payment of $59,000 at the end of the 5-year period.
Required:
1-a. Calculate the present value for the following assuming that the money can be invested at 12%.
1-b. If she can invest money at 12%, which option would you recommend that she accept?
Explanation
The present value of the first option is $140,000, since the entire amount would be received immediately.
The present value of the second option is:
| | |
Annual annuity: $27,000 × 3.605 (Exhibit 13B-2) | $ | 97,335 |
Lump-sum payment: $59,000 × 0.567 (Exhibit 13B-1) | | 33,453 |
Total present value | $ | 130,788 |
|
Thus, Julie should accept the first option, which has a much higher present value.
On the surface, the second option appears to be a better choice because it promises a total cash inflow of $194,000 over the 5-year period ($27,000 × 5 = $135,000; $135,000 + $59,000 = $194,000), whereas the first option promises a cash inflow of only $140,000. However, the cash inflows under the second option are spread out over 5 years, causing the present value to be far less.
Thanks